The Human Cost of Sustainability’s Job Market: Why We Need to Talk About Unemployment in Responsible Investment

rifanmuazin - Wednesday, November 18, 2026 | 00:05
Finance Poetry
The Human Cost of Sustainability’s Job Market: Why We Need to Talk About Unemployment in Responsible Investment

Last year at the PRI in Person conference, participants were deeply engaged in debates surrounding the future of the Principles for Responsible Investment. Discussions buzzed with speculation on how the organization would evolve, adapt to changing regulatory landscapes, and address

the complex demands of global investors navigating a rapidly shifting economic environment.

Yet, returning to the conference this year, that overarching strategic dialogue seemed to fade into the background—at least in the private conversations held in corridors and coffee breaks. Perhaps expectations within the sustainable finance sector have finally reset, or perhaps the PRI has successfully absorbed and acted upon the heavy critiques leveled against it in recent years. Whatever the reason, this year’s discussions carried an entirely different, much more personal protagonist: job loss.

It is a topic that the responsible investment industry urgently needs to confront, because current observations suggest that professionals are failing one another when it comes to navigating career displacement. Based on recent conversations across the sector, the industry appears to sort itself neatly into distinct behavioral profiles when engaging with peers who have suddenly found themselves out of work.

The Four Profiles of Industry Engagement

The ways in which employed sustainable finance professionals interact with unemployed colleagues can be categorized into four distinct archetypes, reminiscent of psychological personality tests.

The first profile is characterized by a stark avoidance strategy, with one industry insider describing it as treating unemployed individuals "like lepers." Colleagues will physically veer away in conversations as if unemployment were contagious, or at the very least, professionally useless, treating any time spent with someone between jobs as a waste of valuable networking currency.

The second profile acts as the professional equivalent of the voyeur. These individuals treat tales of job loss as prime gossip fodder, deriving a quiet, unsettling sense of satisfaction from the fact that they have been spared—at least for the time being. To the casual observer, their intense interest might masquerade as empathy, but it more often reflects a form of psychological vertigo, drawn in by the emptiness below others and the temptation to gaze into the career abyss.

The third profile leans heavily into a "see no evil, speak no evil" approach. When faced with a peer who has lost their position, these individuals will quickly steer the dialogue away from the personal and professional crisis at hand, shifting the focus to broader macroeconomic themes like the adoption rates of transition plans, or the critical importance of nature and a just transition in designing modern climate strategies. A charitable interpretation of this behavior suggests it stems from a misplaced sense of empathy—an effort to avoid shining a harsh spotlight on an uncomfortable circumstance. A more cynical view is that these professionals simply refuse to face the music to which the wider industry is currently dancing.

The final profile is initially viewed as the hero of the narrative: the ally. This is the colleague who immediately steps forward with reassuring promises: "Don’t hesitate to reach out! Let me put you in touch with somebody! Have you seen this job offer?"

Jakob Thomä… on lessons from sustainable finance’s unemployed

While these declarations sound supportive, the reality of being a true ally goes far deeper than offering superficial encouragement during moments of industry turbulence.

Moving Beyond Kind Words

The difficult part of addressing industry unemployment is defining what true allyship actually requires. Kind words are an essential starting point, particularly during moments of acute professional crisis. Most long-standing professionals can recall moments when their own career stability hung in the balance. For instance, reflecting back to 2021, the prospect of sudden unemployment loomed large when a research board decided to file for bankruptcy after a partner chose not to distribute funds received on their behalf.

During those dark weeks, kind words from peers provided crucial emotional ballast until the funding dispute was resolved and the crisis averted. In such moments of vulnerability, people need validation because, as the famous line from the 1990 romantic comedy Pretty Woman illustrates, when people are constantly put down by circumstances, they eventually start to believe it.

Yet, in moments of deep crisis, kind words alone are simply not enough. How many professionals are genuinely putting in the hard work behind the reflexive promises of making introductions and scanning the job market? Anecdotal evidence suggests the follow-through is often lacking.

Challenging Career Dreams and Offering Real Support

Furthermore, offering standard words of encouragement may sometimes be the entirely wrong remedy for a colleague facing structural shifts in the job market. At the conclusion of Pretty Woman, a voiceover famously entreats the audience to "keep on dreamin’," suggesting there is always time to pursue aspirations. But in the current economic reality of sustainable investment, where the pool of candidates wanting to work in the sector frequently outstrips the number of available positions, the best advice is sometimes to change the dream entirely.

The sustainable finance industry is experiencing a phase where some professionals need to hear hard truths rather than hollow affirmations. Encouraging someone to relentlessly pursue a market that has repeatedly rejected them, or blindly cheering on the launch of a consulting venture that serves primarily as a temporary front while job hunting, may feel supportive, but it may actually stem from a reluctance to deliver uncomfortable truths. When an industry has more aspiring workers than open roles, some individuals need honest guidance regarding potential career pivots rather than false hope.

The most pragmatic approach uncovered in recent industry discussions boils down to a fundamental shift in perspective: asking what would actually help.

Rather than assuming what a displaced colleague needs—whether it is superficial words of affirmation, harsh reality checks, specific professional doors opened, or constructive feedback on a pitch—professionals must abandon the collective silence surrounding unemployment. Just as sustainability professionals routinely consult stakeholders to understand their actual needs, the industry must begin consulting its own peers who are facing brutal economic headwinds.

Failing to ask what is truly useful risks repeating the historical oversight seen on Rodeo Drive, where shopkeepers dismissed a customer based on superficial assumptions, missing an opportunity with massive consequences. As the sustainable finance sector continues to evolve through its current growing pains, fostering a culture of genuine, consultative allyship remains an urgent priority for professionals navigating an increasingly competitive job market.

Source : Finance Poetry
Author : rifanmuazin
Editor : Finance Poetry Editorial Team