In 1930, one of history’s most influential economists made a bold prediction that would prove spectacularly wrong. John Maynard Keynes, in his essay “Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren,” predicted that by 2030, people would work only 15 hours per week. As we approach that deadline, the reality couldn’t be more different. Full-time employees in the US work an average of 42.9 hours per week, with many Americans clocking 46.7 hours weekly according to recent surveys.
The Logic Behind Keynes’ Failed Forecast
Keynes’ argument was straightforward: technological advances would make workers more productive, producing more output per hour, leading people to choose leisure over additional work. His reasoning seemed sound – if machines could do more work, humans would need to work less to maintain their standard of living. He imagined that by 2030, people would be “liberated from want” and work no more than fifteen hours weekly, devoting time to leisure and culture.
What Keynes underestimated was human psychology and societal pressures. Rather than trading productivity gains for leisure, we’ve consistently chosen higher consumption and material wealth. The rise of consumer culture, status competition, and lifestyle inflation has kept us working longer hours despite technological advances that should have freed us.
The Dangerous Allure of Expert Predictions
Keynes wasn’t just any economist – he revolutionized economic thinking, and entire schools of thought bear his name. His theories on government intervention and monetary policy continue shaping global economics today. Yet even this intellectual giant missed the mark entirely on one of his most famous predictions.
This serves as a powerful reminder that expertise doesn’t guarantee accurate forecasting, especially about complex human behavior. Today’s equivalent might be tech visionaries predicting universal basic income or artificial intelligence timelines. While these experts possess deep knowledge, their grand theories about societal transformation often overlook unpredictable human factors.
The lesson isn’t to dismiss expertise entirely, but to maintain healthy skepticism about sweeping predictions. As Keynes himself knew, “accurate predictions about the future are difficult, if not impossible”. The wisest approach is to think critically, test ideas against reality, and make decisions based on what works for your specific situation rather than following grand theories blindly.
Brilliance and overconfidence often go hand in hand. Even the smartest minds can be spectacularly wrong about the future.
This blog post is for information only